Showing posts with label competition. Show all posts
Showing posts with label competition. Show all posts

Sunday, September 11, 2011

Winning?

The Awkward Stage--"The Morons Are Winning" (mp3)

As a young teacher, I liked to partake in all of the competitions against students--flag football, basketball, etc. It didn't really matter that much that I was expected to block or that I didn't get in much in a b-ball game. We did it because we lived in the dorms, because we knew the boys, because the kind of trash-talking that went on before and after was part of the friendly rivalry and essential camaraderie that we had with our students.

But soon, a certain element of the faculty took over--the ones who had to win. At that point, there was talk of strategy, of recruiting, meaning talking to faculty who hadn't shown up, but who could help the team, of practicing, rather than just showing up for the game. It wasn't too long after that I stopped playing.

Some years later, after the death of Pete Maravich, a group of over-40 faculty members formed a Geriatric Basketball Association, a weekly outing of friendly/competitive basketball that. There were a couple of us who were allowed to join because we "played like we were over 40." What that really meant was that we understood the spirit of the "league." That spirit involved pick-up games where we tried to make the teams even, where we would play for a long time before we even played for points, where we tolerated the guy who drank wine before we played and could clear out the lane just with his farts or the guy who couldn't shoot at all or the intra-departmental rivalry at point guard or music teacher who didn't know the rules of basketball and just blocked people.

After a couple of years, some younger faculty arrived on the scene, and hearing of the weekly game, asked if they could play. Almost immediately, you can guess what happened. The young Physics teacher who still fashioned himself a skilled post player was bashing bodies with an older guy who knew someone who knew someone who let him into the league. And there were heated words and stand-offs and people storming out of the game on at least one occasion.

You see the pattern. It would be too easy and a mistake, I think, to put the blame on the young. This isn't about young vs. old; it's about the need to win, to dominate, to crush one's opponent at the expense of everything else.

I see it even now in my Fantasy Football league. Sure, all of us would like to win, would like to have the $100 that goes to the overall winner, but most of us know that our league was formed as a social league. It is indeed kind of humorous when you think about it, grown men thinking that they "own" a team and getting so fired up about winning with that team that they are no-nonsense at the draft and get into the minutae of league rules and don't really engage all that much socially. It's something that all of us who play, I'd guess, have been caught up in at one time or another. Maybe.

I just feel it a little more right now. Maybe it's the economy (which is a convenient excuse for anything anyone can think of--not having sex? It's probably the economy) and there's someone who doesn't so much want to win as feels like he needs to win. If you get into our league needing to win the $100 first place, you are in the wrong place. Fantasy Football is far more about luck and who you happen to pick up in the middle of the season than in any strategy on Draft Day or whatever research you may have done in preparation for it.

I suspect it's bigger than that. The need to win has become so pervasive in our society that, for many people, loyalty to a sports team or a presidential candidate or a date is unlikely to survive any serious downturn. We're as fickle as the politicians who base decisions on the polls that capture our fickleness. And what we--as schools, as political parties, as participants in competitions--will do to win has long since breached the boundaries of acceptable behavior.

Along the way, just at this school, I can remember softball tournament started by a sophomore leadership organization. In its best moments, it was the all-school tournament where I could play on a team called "The 700 Club," which had nothing to do with the Christian Network show and everything to do with having to have at least a 700 on at least one part of the SAT. Needless to say, the team did not go far, but the fun, the camaraderie, the self-awareness that the team wasn't about winning, that's what the tournament did for these boys.

It became the tournament where a 10th grade student umpire's call at second base caused him to get chewed out by a fully-grown, supposedly-adult faculty member. Where in the same faculty/student tournament, faculty members recruited teams a year in advance, and where faculty members got into shouting matches with other faculty members' wives who were sitting up in the stands. That the tournament no longer exists is now blamed on a shift in the varsity sports alignment, but those of us who have been here know that the fun went out of the tournament long before it died its slow, eventual death.

The funniest, not-so-funniest aspect of having to win is that the drive to get there destroys everything around it, so that by the time everything is in place for the best possible chance of winning, there isn't anyone who still wants to play. Yeah, that makes me sad, in a way, but I like it. It's the revenge of those of us who are not ultra-competitive. I guess it's how we win.

Monday, June 13, 2011

Women Are From Venus, Men Are From The Toy, Game And Sports Departments At Target

Au Revoir Simone--"The Boys Of Summer" (mp3)

This past weekend, I smoked meat, drank beer, sweated until my armpits stank, turned up music too loud, swore plenty, foraged for fire wood and then threw unnecessary logs on the fire, stayed up too late, brushed off ticks, made a lot of either disparaging or self-deprecating remarks, shoveled cake in my mouth after midnight, made half-hearted efforts to clean things up. And, most of all, I played games.

Yep. You guessed it. Men together.

It was the occasion of my friend's 40th birthday, a surprise gathering in the mountains of West Virginia, in Fayetteville, centerpiece of the New River Gorge and self-proclaimed "Coolest Small Town In America." His brother-in-law rented a vacation home for 4 days and we all chipped in and snuck in and pulled off the surprise and made quite a weekend of it. There were seven of us.

My wife went on a "girl trip" last summer, but she didn't really like it, and, or at least didn't like it for very long. Since she's never said that much about it (except when she called all the time while she was there), I can't really say why she didn't connect with it. The subject did come up on Saturday, when a bunch of us were leaning against the deck railing in the backyard, either smoking or watching meat smoke.

"What do women when they go on trips like this?" somebody asked.
"Talk," someone else responded. "They sit around and talk."

It wasn't said as a put-down. It was said very matter-of-factly. I'd guess it's probably true, but I'm not hanging my hat on it, having never been on such a trip, though I have been on a "couples" trip or two, and they have tended in that direction. Let's just say that the crowd in West Virginia didn't have the "personal statement of Christian faith" discussion that we had down in Charleston last summer. When we weren't shopping or eating in that city, we were back in the apartment chatting.

Men, on the other hand, play games and sports and activities. Before I arrived, they had spent the day whitewater rafting. In the backyard, a choice between Ladder Ball and Cornhole, games played at all times of the morning and day and at night until it was too dark to see. During the late evenings, there was poker for the foolish. One day, the brave went zip-lining, and the rest of us journeyed into the gnat-infested woods to play Frisbee golf.

But everything, and I mean everything, was a competition, not only in this crowd, but in every all-male gathering. The one night we went out to dinner, as soon as we sat down, someone instituted a rule, I can't remember the name of it (and not because I lost!), where if you were caught holding your beer with your primary hand, you had to chug the drink. Luckily, I have slight ambidexiterity from my father, and drink with my right hand even though I'm left-handed.

Even music, as I have mentioned in these pages before, is a matter of one-upsmanship. While we didn't engage in the legendary "Ipod Wars," listening to music with a bunch of guys most certainly does not involve putting Sarah McLachlan on in the background and being done with it. Instead, it's about getting your turn with your Ipod playing your songs that show who you are and why your songs are perfect for the moment. And taking the heat if it doesn't turn out. I'm proud to say that I introduced the concept of women who make music to this Ipod crowd. With limited success.

I celebrate this friendly competitiveness. It certainly made the weekend more fun, but it also speaks to something larger. Men have got to have at least a little something at stake (their egos, if nothing else) in order to fully engage in life. They have got to be able to prove to themselves that they can face their fears or get a little better at something new than they were the first time they did it. Or they need to know that there is another crack at it, whatever it is, waiting out there. They need the nod of approval from their compadres, the high five, even if it's only for one decent throw, shot, toss, save, or hand in a long, losing effort.

Like Beowulf and his thanes in the mead hall "forgetting the woes of the world," modern men still lose themselves in activities and games, beers and meals. They communicate with bottles clunked together, shared songs, the communal lure of the fire, and words that focus mainly just on what they are doing right then. Otherwise, they'd have to sit around and actually talk to each other.

Wednesday, May 5, 2010

A Glitch in the Step Matrix

Bit by Bit (from Fletch) - Stephanie Mills (mp3)
Work Itself Out - Roadside Graves (mp3)

Progress, it must be remembered, is best as a dance, not a march.

Often the only way forward also requires steps to the side, and steps back. Marching is against human nature. It's forced, not organic. When progress is forced, it creates friction, tension, unease. Dancing, on the other hand, requires an understanding of what the body's natural inclinations are, combined with tons of practice and work. But dancing, when done right, is not forced. It is free of tension. It looks completely fluid and simple. Thus the lovely saying, "Free your mind, and your ass will follow."

So let's apply this notion to the progression of race relations in America. Specifically, what happens to this progress when a white sorority gets all uppity and wins a national step competition?

That's exactly the question forced upon us this February in Atlanta, when the Zeta Tau Alpha chapter of the University of Arkansas at Fayetteville won the Sprite Step Off.

Most of BOTG's readers, I suspect, know little if any about Stepping. Personally, I'm only just knowledgeable and educated enough to get myself in trouble. When I was a freshman, my dorm RA was the president-elect of UNC's Alpha Phi Alpha fraternity, and because he was easily the most influential African-American presence in my young and clueless life to that point, I was given several mini-lectures on the history and significance of stepping. I also witnessed two official step shows and at least a dozen impromptu step performances in the Pit outside the school's main dining hall.

Something about the live performance, about witnessing a step show happen right there in front of you, multiplies the power of the experience. In this, it's very much like hockey, which in my opinion is the sport whose awesomeness is the most powerfully affected by watching it live. (Football, soccer and basketball, on the other hand, translate far too well to TV, which is why they are the world's most popular sports.)

Anyway, a bunch of white chicks from Arkansas won a national competition intended for, if not explicitly exclusive to, historically-black sororities. When they were announced as winners to the predominantly-black Atlanta audience, the crowd reacted by gathering in a circle, holding up empty soda bottles, and announcing that they'd like to teach the world to sing in perfect harmony.

Ha. Of course that wasn't the reaction.

Here was the reaction, according to the Washington Post.

Here was the reaction, according to The Root.com.

If you read the YouTube comments -- thousands of them -- in response to the various videos of their performance (a 2-minute excerpt is embedded at the bottom of this post), you will see a display of all levels of IQ, knowledge, and tolerance warring and wrestling with what all of this means.

Here's my reaction to the reaction.

First, the immediate and negative response of the crowd was something any idiot should have seen coming. History is full of competitions where a square peg attempts to fit in a traditionally round hole, emerges victorious, and is consequently despised by large parts of the traditional public. Jackie Robinson. Althea Gibson. Calvin Peete. Lamar Latrell. Daniel Laruso. Herbie The Love Bug. But I digress.

We look back on these moments and admire the people (or cars) involved. People my age tend to undervalue and underappreciate the struggles and scorn the great groundbreaking athletes endured. There's no way I, at 38 and white, can truly appreciate appreciate that, when Hank Aaron rounded the bases after breaking Maris' home run record, it lingered in the back of his mind that someone might well try to kill him.

It is entirely irrational to look to a bunch of binge-drinking white college chicks from Arkansas to be game-changers in the world of racial progress. But, if you look at the dance of progress in history, we must at least acknowledge that what happened that February night in Atlanta will be considered a vital and important "step" in this never-ending move towards something better. (Sorry for the pun. Couldn't help it.)

Now if we can just get Darius Rucker to win the seed spitting contest at the Redneck Olympics, our dance of racial progress will surely be complete.

Monday, November 16, 2009

Vince Lombardi Can Kiss My Pasty White A$$

The Secret of My Success - Night Ranger (mp3)
Everybody's a VIP to Someone - The Go! Team (mp3)
(Link removed due to DRSM violation warning.)

It's all because of me and my old man. God, I fucking hate him. He's like, he's like this mindless machine I can't even relate to anymore. "Andrew, you've got to be number one. I won't tolerate any losers in this family. Your intensity is for shit." You son of a bitch. You know, sometimes I wish my knee would give and I wouldn't be able to wrestle anymore. He could forget all about me.
-- Andrew Clarke (Emilio Estevez), The Breakfast Club

My daughters' U10 soccer team won three games in a row on Saturday to take home the league championship. No one on their team had ever played select soccer. Only three of the eight girls had ever played together before, and two of the three were my girls.

Oh yeah. And I was their coach.

The Vampires -- yeah, that was our team name -- weren't superbly talented, and their coach had never played in or coached a game of actual soccer in his whole life. The only reason I was the coach was because our original coach backed out, and the only way the five girls who wanted to play together could was if I were willing to do it. My first email to parents included something to this effect: "If your goal is to win, or if you expect your girls to dramatically improve, this is a bad idea. I can only promise you that we will try to have fun and teach what we can." Trust me that I'm not being humble when I say we barely met our meager goals.

Very rarely does having a philosophy that values other things above winning actually get rewarded with winning. If victory isn't the priority, it's not fair to expect to be rewarded with victory, right? So please allow me this rare opportunity to bask in it.

Granted, a lot of serendipitous factors played into our ultimate victory and were much more important than anything I did or any philosophy I espoused:
  1. It rained all fucking season. More than half our games were postponed or cancelled, as were more than half our practices. This didn't hurt our team as much as it did teams who actually have great and beneficial practices.
  2. In the tournament, we were given a Christmas gift of a blind draw. Three of the four debatably better teams all played in the other half of the bracket.
  3. Because all teams started the season with small rosters -- 7 or 8 players for teams that play six to a side -- injuries and absences made it tough to field a team. Several coaches used "pick-ups" all year to beef up their team, and those pick-ups were frequently U10 and U8 select players. (And trust me, a select U8 is regularly better than an average U10 player.) These coaches asked that this tournament make exception to standard rules and allow pick-ups. I opposed and said that we should play 5 v 5 when necessary rather than allow for what I lovingly call "assassins."
  4. All seven of our girls showed up for the tourney. We played the last two games 5 v 5, and the other team had no subs.

In short, we had a bench, we hadn't been padding our team, and superior coaches didn't have as much time to improve their players. Add up those factors and my scrub team of very decent soccer girls, playing under a philosophy of "have fun and work together," won a title.

One of our girls hurt her knee the weekend before. She could hardly run, and when she did, she resembled Forrest Gump when he was on those leg braces. But I played her anyway. I called her "SuperSub," because her job was to go in when any of the other girls were tired. And she gave it her all even though she had no business being out there if winning was our goal.

When those three whistles blew, and those girls knew they'd won, each of them could know confidently that they had played a part in winning. From the injured sub to our stud goalie to my daughters. It wasn't just Self-Esteem-Boosting Lefty Dad talking. Each girl on our team contributed an invaluable part of the victories. To be able to say that, and mean it, and see in their eyes that they believed it... that was far better than the mere victories. (Unfortunately, it's soooo much easier to believe that shit when you also win.)

To say coaching is taken a little too seriously in the 21st Century is like saying that walking on water is kinda neat. Nerds like me believe coaches are given far too much power, influence and credit.

The way some people at our school talk, you'd think coaches invented the light bulb and helped ensure world peace. Too often, we hire teachers based more on what coaching vacancies they can fill rather than whether they teach well. We'll take a B- teacher who coaches the right thing over an A+ teacher who's willing to learn how to coach. (And it's not just our school. I dare you to find a handful of male principals in any public system who weren't coaches before they got promoted.)

Meanwhile, our school's history is chock full of smart teachers who didn't know jack shit about their sport somehow leading teams to state titles. But we ignore that and instead hire "professional" coaches; that is, people who find a sport more important than all the other stuff involved in the process of education. And we apparently live with this decision by saying that what kids learn on athletic fields carries with them the rest of their lives. (As opposed to, you know, geometry and The Scarlet Letter, which don't have nearly the staying power as lessons learned from wrestling. In math terms, that's Cross-Body Ride > x.)

Ever read the infamous email from the man I call the Green Death Soccer Coach? It's quite the work of art. Even though I think there's a chance the dude was totally kidding, I can say quite confidently that had he been in the South, he would never have faced the kinds of negativity and consequences he saw up in Massachusetts. Down here, we promote these coaches. These dudes are now principals. Or Nick Saban.

Competition and competitiveness in their proper places, in the proper perspective, are wonderful and powerful things. But our society of parents and adults looks and sounds more and more like Andrew Clarke's dad every day. And either too many of us seem to think it's OK, or we don't care enough to change it.

In the finals, the other coach took a girl out in the final six minutes because she wouldn't get back on defense when we scored our final goal. The girl was big. She'd been playing non-stop the whole game. What's the big shock here? But he basically conceded defeat when we played five of the last eight minutes in a 5v4 game. To teach her a lesson, I guess. That being 10 and utterly exhausted is no excuse.

I'm a little competitive. Otherwise I wouldn't be celebrating the fact that my girls kicked the collective asses of all those serious coaches obsessed with winning. At this very moment, I feel very much like Bud Adams in the Buffalo luxury box. That's what a few beers can do to someone who knows it's not easy to keep the value of victory in perspective. So you'll have to forgive me if, for this one brief moment, the forces of Fun and Perspective won out over The League of Winning Is Everything Jocks and I cheer a little harder than the moment deserved.

God bless Night Ranger, but it's a miracle there's any cliches left after they used so many of them on this one song. And God bless The Go! Team for making songs that sound both sooo so '70s yet soooo so kewl.

Monday, September 7, 2009

"Come On!!"

Glory of True Love - John Prine (mp3)
Serves You Right - Manuok (mp3)

There was a time, decades ago, when ordinary average men would sit around a television set to watch tennis. They did so to watch two seemingly ordinary average American men -- perhaps with a bit more temper than average -- claw and growl and bark their way to the top of the heap.

John McEnroe and Jimmy Connors seemed blue collar. I don't know their life stories, but I know they seemed like guys everyone could root for, so long as you could suffer their brashness and their impatience for little things like rules and decorum. Maybe that's what made them so American.

In the last days of the wooden racket and the early days of the crappy metal ones, serves didn't clock in at 120mph. Forehand blasts didn't leave rubber burn marks on a court surface. In the days of the wooden racket, power was less vital than placement and strategery. You got the feeling McEnroe and Connors survived the circuit more for their bulldog stubbornness than for their power.

My own personal love of watching tennis exploded in 1985. I was bored and watching HBO that summer and witnessed the highlights of a second-round victory by this German teenager named Boris Becker. He was diving and scraping and clawing all over the court. Becker had a lot of bulldog in him, but his rise also marked the early stages of Power Tennis, where strength and height became crucial factors.

Becker and Stefan Edburg became rivals du jour, engaging in serve-and-volley shooting matches that often went five sets but rarely seemed to last more than three or four volleys.

Oddly, it's probably Becker's success -- and the advancing technology of cannon-esque rackets -- that brought on the assassin-like coldness of the last 15 or so years of tennis. Jim Courier and Michael Chang had something of Connors in their game, with the endurance and the stubbornness, but they seemed to lack the personality to seem bigger. And maybe it was also because the days when endurance could compete with power were gone.

Seriously, other than maybe Andre Agassi, who lost a lot of his court personality as he got older, what other great male from the last 15 years has had a smidge of personality? Sampras? Puhleeze. Federer? Knock it off. Nadal? That's as close as you get, which isn't close.

On the women's side, things have been a little better. But where once roamed the petite and adorable likes of Tracy Austin and Chris Evert now roam Amazonian hulk-people. The Williams sisters, Lindsay Davenport, and the Eastern Bloc women, where Sharapova is considered "lithe" at 6'2" and 130 pounds. The hopes of the underdog rest exclusively on the likes of Justine Henin, who retired but hit #1 several times at a mere 5'6" and 120-ish. I cannot possibly explain to you just how difficult that must be. Yet Justine didn't exactly have me running to turn on my TV. She was a teensy bulldog of a gal, but still not particularly compelling.

What I'm saying is, tennis hasn't had any good characters in a long time. It's crammed with amazing talent, raw force, and even decent looks. But personality? Not a lick.

For a brief, shining moment this week, we've seen what tennis could be if the right people could find their way up the ladder. This enlightenment has come in the form of Georgia teenager Melanie Oudin. At 17 and unseeded, she's the first female since Serena Williams to make it to the quarterfinals of the US Open at such a young age, and Serena did it a decade ago.

This girl is mesmerizing. I haven't watched this much tennis in a long, long time, and it ain't because she's hot. Although Ms. Oudin is cute enough, she also looks like the kind of friend you want with you if you get jumped by 20 ninja, because she'd stay in the fight and prolly take out a dozen of the bastards, even if she had to bite and scratch and claw. Or donkey-kick.

In David Foster Wallace's essay damning Tracy Austin's autobiography ("How Tracy Austin Broke My Heart"), he realizes that the quality that tends to make for superior athletes often makes for boring people: they live in the moment. They can bury the fears of the future and the ghosts of the past and completely commit themselves to The Now. (Writers, on the other hand, tend to live in exactly the opposite way, with equally damning results.)

If you ever liked watching tennis. If you ever wondered whether you should give it a shot. If you can tolerate watching any women's sport at all. Tune in on Wednesday and watch Melanie Oudin. I don't know if she's going to win, but I know it's going to be almost impossible to take my eyes off her. She's what tennis could be and should be about.

And you'll be sure to hear what is apparently the Ultimate Tennis Saying for women of all ages and from all countries: "COME ON!!!"

P.S. If you watch Oudin in interviews, she is a perfect match for Anna Farris' movie star character from "Lost in Translation."

Monday, July 20, 2009

Waterlogged (Part One)

Slow Dog - Belly (mp3)
Pretty Deep - Tanya Donnelly (mp3)

My two daughters just concluded their third summer of competitive swimming. I love my daughters. I do not love swim meets.

Good modern-age parenting requires that parents choose at least two or three regular child-centered activities where the parent's sole responsibility is to transport said children to and from said activity. During said activity, the supreme modern parent attentively views their child's participation; the modestly decent parent fills time with book-reading or phone-talking; and the subpar parent just drops 'em off and picks 'em up.

The line of demarcation has changed significantly in the last 30 years. When I was in elementary school, playing baseball and taking piano lessons, my parents were considered on the higher end merely for paying the fees and driving me. In my seven years of actually playing baseball (as opposed to sitting on the bench and pinch hitting once the game was decided), my parents might have watched two dozen games. And by "my parents" I mean one of them. One year my team (the Reds) made the finals of the playoffs and both of them showed up. That was almost an aligning of the planets kind of event. I won the game with one of those miracle catches that can only be made by someone who is on the verge of a nervous breakdown and whose skills are very much in question. That is to say, I took a routine fly ball and turned it into a miracle basket catch that found me falling backward and basically flipping over.

On the one hand, you'd think maybe a parent would witness this and say, "Holy shit. I've been missing some incredible drama!" But on the other hand, if you were my parents, you'd say, "Holy shit. There's 99 ways Billy could have screwed that up, and we witnessed the one time he managed to find success. Maybe we should quit while we're ahead."

Not that I'm bitter. In fact, I'm totally jealous. I'm trapped in a generation where parents are more obligated to care, to function as an engaged part of the audience. Hence, my attendance at all but two of this year's swim meets, the two I missed due to obligations to my teensy infant boy who doesn't like water, crowds, heat, or anything else about a swim meet. (Yes, that's called Good Evolutionary Instinct.)

Below, and on Thursday, I will offer some random thoughts and observations inspired by yet another season of swimming, organized in subheads for your simpler reading pleasure. [I'm technically on vacation this week, drinking massive amounts of alcohol while also totally being responsible with the supervision of my children. So if anything below or on Thursday fails to make sense, I blame it on all of that.]

BAD MATH: SWIMMING'S MISERABLE TIME "R.O.I."


When it comes to being great athletic supporters for their kids, several of my closest friends are, in this particular portion of the Standardized Parental Aptitude Test, supreme. They score in the high 700s on this part. Granted, all three I'm thinking of are baseball parents to boys. But I work with and am friends with a man who scores a full-on 790 or 800 on this portion no matter what sports his daughter or son play. Soccer, baseball, swimming, running, whatever.

This area is not my strong suit. I'm fighting to keep my score at around 590, which is good enough to get me into your standard SEC level of parenting, but it blows my shot at the Ivy Leagues. As should be obvious from above, I blame my parents. More specifically, I blame growing up thinking that it shouldn't be considered crucial that my parents were there to watch for me to find happiness and enjoyment in an activity.

But I gotta buck up and accept a change in the culture. So. When it comes to supporting your child's sporting adventures, attitude is about 70% of the battle. Knowing enough to be useful and advisory (but not knowing too much, which can be detrimental) is another 10%. And the environment -- the coach, the other parents, the other kids -- is the 20% you can't control.

But dammit, I'm so much better as a soccer parent or as a basketball parent. With those events, even if your kid isn't a starter, their performance and play relates quite directly to what those other kids are doing on the field/court. And if your kid is playing, then you can totally train your focus on your kid. But with swimming? Or wrestling? Or gymnastics? With individual sports like this, you're investing three or four hours of your life to watch your child perform a grand total of maybe two or three minutes. The rest of the time, you sit around trying to act like you give one rat's ass about the other kids who are swimming, including that 17-year-old boy who's wearing swim briefs so small you think he might have stolen them from your 7-year-old daughter.

Thus the Great Paradox of Sports Support #1: I will be vigilant about making sure my daughters know that participation in team sports is not all about them. The team does not revolve around them, but rather vice-versa. However, when it comes to observing your child's team sport, it's totally OK to be all about your own kid. It's a paradox, but I don't believe it's hypocrisy. 

To be continued on Thursday...

Tanya Donnelly was the lead singer of Belly before venturing off on her own. The first is from the album Star, and the second from Lovesongs for Hangovers. Both can be found at iTunes or Amazon.com.

Monday, October 6, 2008

My Kid Can Beat Up Your Honors Student

If I Had a Boat - Lyle Lovett (mp3)
Down to Earth - Peter Gabriel (mp3)

Most of us want so much for our children that it hurts us. This longing causes weirdos like me actual, physical pain -- maybe that's just more proof I need to exercise. It also takes a tremendous emotional toll, because we can't give them everything, dammit. Granted, good parents wouldn't give them everything even if we could, 'cuz if you could just hand them everything, they fail to earn the intangibles for themselves. But you want it for them nonetheless. You want them to have tulips and smiley faces and all the hugs and warm fuzzies the world has out there to offer.

Over the weekend, I was witness to two entirely separate, yet completely related, parental groups. First, I took my oldest daughter to run in a county-wide elementary school race. Each grade level, separated by gender, ran a mile. Each school was limited to a handful per grade. Perhaps because she inherited her mother's athleticism, or perhaps because she's been in soccer for several years and loves riding her bicycle and expending loads of energy, she made the cut. (Which officially puts her ahead of my entire adolescent life when it comes to making teams.)

One of Avery's oldest friends won the whole damn thing. She was the best out of some 300+ girls in the county. She goes to a school where they form teams a year early to encourage conditioning (and arguably to win these kinds of races). That school had five girls finish in the top 20. Two of them run 6 1/2-minute miles. They're 8 years old. Still, watching those two kids, waaay out in front and verging on tears and pushing themselves, was amazing, and I cheered on our friend's girl. Then, more than 100 runners later, I cheered on my own girl. My pride in both girls was overwhelming, mostly 'cuz I'm one of those pathetic guys who would have been shot for snoring too loud in the days of the Wild West.

After breakfast and a brief respite, we were off to the soccer field. My 7-year-old had played her game while we were at the race, so I missed her game. But Avery's game was intense, and her team played well even if they lost 6-2 (which is 42-14 in American Football language; it never seems like quite the blowout until you put it in American Football terms).

The other team had one of the most skilled young girls I've seen yet. She stopped the ball on a dime. Passed with eyebrow-raising precision. Could kick the ball hard enough to leave little comet trails coming out of the thing.

Most of me gets nauseated by this. I think to myself, "Why does your daughter need to be Mia Hamm-esque in third grade? What good does it do, really?" I look at these parents who are hellbent on making their children so exceptional at something and think, how much of the rest of everything did you take away from your kid's life?

Does anyone really ask that of Tiger Woods? Does anyone ask that of the Williams sisters or Shawn Johnson and Nastia Liukin? Maybe they do, but somehow at that level it seems to get past my radar. Apparently, I can be indignant and judgmental about it unless it pays off. This makes my hypocrisy all the more glaring. It's like me being OK with the idiots who obsessively play the lottery once they hit the Powerball, but mocking and insulting the ones who don't.

And what I've begun to wonder lately is, do all the parents like me, who want so desperately to do right by our children, to not obsess over one single facet of their lives or interests, actually do their children as much of an injustice as those wacky soccer moms and football dads and violin moms and mock trial dads? Maybe we're so afraid of pigeonholing our children that we throw them down this big crater, a hole so big the kids don't even know where to start digging.

"The world is your oyster" is misleading, because an oyster isn't that big of a thing. The way I raise my children, maybe I'm teaching them that "The world is your ocean." And maybe that's not quite the great and positive message I think it should be. Maybe the ocean is too big. Too much. Eventually they'll need to find some place in that vast liquid expanse to call home.

Am I so busy trying to prevent them from becoming focused on or obsessed with one single thing too early that I risk preventing them from calling any single place home? Do we non-obsessive types risk raising wandering and aimless kids?

Maybe part of it is jealousy, too. The way I was raised, the values I was given, made me above average at lots of different things, but I never won a race of any kind, a contest of any kind. I was never The Absolute Best at anything (with the mildly debatable exception of winning my high school's award as its best English student), but I was staunchly competent in many arenas. Do I see these 8-year-olds running at blinding speeds, these soccer kids playing years ahead of themselves, and want them to burn out so that I can feel better? See? That's why we didn't put you in tennis lessons so soon. That's why we only dabbled in piano or swimming or acting camp. We didn't want you to burn out. We didn't want to choose your passion for you.

As Lloyd Dobbler so brilliantly put it a few decades ago, "I can't figure it all out tonight, sir, so I'm just gonna hang with your daughter."


"If I Had a Boat" is from Lovett's first album, Pontiac. "Down to Earth" is from the WALL-E soundtrack. Both can be found on iTunes or Amazon.com's mp3 site.

Sunday, August 3, 2008

Men, Part 3: The Competitors

King Curtis (featuring Duane Allman)--"Games People Play" (mp3)
The Who--"I Don't Even Know Myself (live)" (mp3)

I am blessed, I mean truly blessed, to have a number of hyper-competitive friends. That means that I can study them and try to find out how and why they work. Internally, I don't have a good understanding of the need to win. I mean, it's nice to win. I like to win. But the need to win as often as possible and for that to be the ultimate goal, that's what I don't get.

GAMBLING EXAMPLE: Two friends and I take a trip to Las Vegas. At the slot machines, one other friend and I decide to play the nickel slots for three reasons: 1) our money will last a long time, 2) we really don't care if we win, we're just enjoying hanging out, and 3) we get the free drinks even in the nickel slots area. My other friend, who outside of gambling is one of the most competitive people I know, is there to win. He plays the dollar slots, hoping to make the big kill, and in 10 minutes all of his gambling money for the trip is gone and he sulks the rest of the time.

I say that I am not competitive, but that is not entirely true; better put, I am extremely competitive in a super-secret kind of way, a kind of closet hyper-competitive. Mostly, with myself. I feel a sense of pride when I put in a good performance. But I'm always amazed when I am in the presence of the must-win-at-any-cost kind of competitor. Especially when I can tell that on some level, the competition has taken him over.

Maybe I'm setting up an artificial distinction.

Certainly, the person who competes with others so passionately is also competing with himself. Certainly, in the team context, the player who puts forth his best competitive effort is serving both his team and himself. Even in individual sports, the super-competitor has the potential, with his performance, to elevate the efforts of others.

The best golf I ever played occurred when I played with three other golfers who were far better than I was. Of course, they weren't competing with me, they were just good, and I wanted to be good, too. I was not trying to beat them; I was trying to better myself.

But when the super-competitor revs up, I shut down. Why? Because I know that he has to win, and that, in some strange way, makes me want him to win. To keep the peace. So he can save face. So we don't have the play the game incessantly until he does win. I don't know. You pick. It's probably one of those reasons. Certainly I don't let him win; I don't have that kind of skill.

This is why I'd make a lousy coach: in 1972, I was a third-string benchwarmer on the "varsity" middle school team, Mt. Lebanon, Pennsylvania. We had a good team (that I had little to do with--I'd get in for some clean-up minutes once in awhile) and with one game to go in the season, we clinched the Section 8 championship. This made me absolutely certain that those of us who had been sitting on the bench all season would get the lion's share of the playing time. Then Coach Hobaugh announced in our victorious lockerroom: "Of course, we want to finish the season with a win." That one statement undercut the season, and not just for me. In a half-thought-out attempt to involve the whole team and still win the game, Coach Hobaugh created a hybrid starting team of a couple of first-stringers and three second-stringers. Those left-out first teamers immediately branded the new starters, "The Buddies." The morale of the team was broken, the players had no chemistry, and we lost that last game anyway. I did get to play and produced some more points than usual during my slightly-expanded minutes. In the locker room after the game, after the coach bitched us out for playing a lackluster game, I told my friend Dean, "Well, at least I played well." He warned me to be quiet, that coach might hear me, but I thought, why worry? The season's over and the coach who had to keep winning had already destroyed the vibe of a good season and it wasn't about team anymore anyway. It was about winning.

For me, probably the quintessential internal competitor is Kevin Costner's character in Tin Cup. As he stands on the golf course, hitting ball after ball after ball and saying "another" and "another" and "another," it's obvious that any other player on the course, or in the competition, has long since fallen away as he tries to achieve his best athletic self. It's understood that this is a fatalistic proposition and that the getting the girl and all of that requires some Hollywood manufacturing.

OK, so here's what I think the problem with competition is: the stuff that fuels it so often. If you think about it, if you want to whip someone into a hyper-competitive frenzy, you appeal to his baser instincts through the use of taunts, goads, jabs, boasts, comparisons, and any other kind of juice-stirring, possibly even involving his mother. That will get him going. Getting someone to be hyper-competitve is not unlike getting him jealous. All you have to do is beat him or create the possibility that you're going to beat him.

And his goal is likely no nobler--it's total domination. Because he has to go for the jugular, he's going to stick it to you, run up the score, totally own you, avenge whatever needs avenging, better yet, beat you every time to begin with, and plan his world around those competitions. If he does lose, you'd think the sky had fallen. If by some freak chance he loses to you, you'll have to play again until he wins. If he's a coach, the loss to you will eat away at him all year until he gets another chance.

And that's the other part of the problem: gaming and competing are social activities. Unless you are at the professional or organized levels, it behooves you to create an environment where others will want to play again. That's hard to do if you absolutely must win as often as possible and avenge your losses when you lose.

I know that this hyper-competitive mentality is part of what it means to be a man in our struttin', high-fivin', take-no-prisoners society and I suspect that the bottom line is that all men want to win. They just find their own competitions. Sometimes when I put the food on the table I'll ask my family, "Who else in Chattanooga is eating a meal this good tonight?" But I think where I come down a bit differently than the norm is that I admire the great performance more than the victory, the camaraderie more than the domination. If the two coincide, even better. I also admire the warrior who lives to fight another day more than a flash-in-the-pan who notches up a few quick victories. Unfortunately, I'm afraid I don't understand the hyper-competitive need to win anymore than I do my own lack thereof. I suspect, as always, childhood, which for me would be the relentless competitions with my older brother. Another. Another. Another.

"Games People Play" comes from the Duane Allman Anthology; "I Don't Even Know Myself" was playedby the "World's Greatest Rock 'n Roll Band" live at the Isle of Wight Festival in 1970. Both are at Itunes.