Showing posts with label intelligence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label intelligence. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 10, 2010

Maybe She's Born With It... Maybe It's Maybelline!

Born Secular - Jenny Lewis + the Watson Twins (mp3)
When Your Mind's Made Up - Glen Hansard + Marketa Irglova (mp3)

At a school I know, the following occurred.

Two administrators stood backstage as the school recognized the top 25% of the graduating GPAs. These nerds were being inducted into a Phi Beta Kappa/Cum Laude kind of organization, a group that does nothing, that exists solely to recognize good GPAs. Sadly, it's the one way some of these kids get recognized for what they do well and what they contribute to the school culture. Kind of like earning a letter just for sitting the bench and keeping stats for varsity baseball.

One administrator, arguably the second most-influential person at this particular school, leaned over to my friend and said, "I don't applaud for something a kid's born with."

Then, as the nerds were walking off the stage with their pieces of paper, acknowledging their good grades, this administrator said the following to them: "Congratulations on your genes, ladies and gentlemen!"

This story was relayed to me because, obviously, I was one of those nerds in high school who made Cum Laude and was never even good enough to sit the bench for an athletic team.

Apparently, how much work and time and effort I put into becoming academically successful was irrelevant, because I was born with my intelligence. Apparently, neither Shaquille O'Neal nor Adrian Peterson were born with athletic gifts or, as they say, "natural talent."

Any nerd would be understandably haunted by this story. The jock administrator just gave our entire geeky way of life a philosophical wedgie (or if you prefer, a swirlie), proclaiming that good grades don't deserve recognition like good tackles or good dunks or good golf shots. And this man, this fan of "genetic" intelligence, is the man who hires teachers and shapes the culture of the school where he works in vast ways.

Then I read the following excerpt from a NYT Book Blog about DRiVE by Daniel H. Pink:

For example, in the chapter titled “Mastery,” Pink presents the research conducted by Carol Dweck, a professor of psychology at Stanford. One of her theories is that there are (once again) two kinds of people when it comes to intelligence. There are those with an “entity theory” of human intelligence, viewing it as “a finite supply that we cannot increase.” Then there are those who subscribe to an “incremental theory,” believing that intelligence is something you continuously build and shape over time. Pink breaks it down nicely: “In one view, intelligence is something you demonstrate; in the other, it’s something you develop.” It’s a useful frame. Is life a stage on which you constantly must perform, or prove, your intelligence to others? Or is it a library, where you gain knowledge and skills from what surrounds you. How you answer such questions, Pink argues, determines how you will react to setbacks, and how serious you are at mastering a set of skills. It might also influence how you react to books like “Drive.” Do you consider the arguments dispassionately, looking for ideas you can use? Or do you bristle at the suggestion that you need to make some changes? (I've been bristling. Now I feel bad about that bristling, and so am bristling about that.)

Reading this didn't cool my anger, but it's given me a way to diagnose his myopia, to see intelligence the way this administrator sees it. To this guy, intelligence is demonstrated, not developed.

You'll have to forgive the snootery here, but this was clearly a guy who attended a shitty high school, the kind of guy whose workload in high school consisted of work that could be done on a school bus or while Mom was getting dinner ready. I know this because intelligence never felt remotely inherited for me. I worked my ass off for it. I obsessed for it. I fought like hell and competed with gritted or grinding teeth to push my way into the top 20% of my graduating class even though I'd been told in seventh grade that I'd done so poorly on the entrance exam that I was one of the last two boys admitted to the school.

I'm not asking for you to be impressed; I'm only asking that you don't tell me I was innately born with it. My ability to see through brick walls? My prehensile tail? My 14" penis? Yes, I was born with all those. But my intelligence? No, motherf*#ker, I P90X'd the hell out of my feeble brains as a lad, and I just can't think of many things more personally insulting to me than to suggest otherwise.

My oldest daughter is friends with a brilliant Indian girl at her school. Twice now Avery has said to me, "She's so smart. Everything's easy for her," and both times I stopped everything to lovingly correct her. Her Indian friend is smart because her parents expect her to master academics like Southern parents expect their kids to master a sport. She trains. She works. She reads. For every hour that my studious and modestly intellectually curious daughter puts into her school work, her Indian friend puts in two, three, four hours. It doesn't come easy. Nothing comes easy. Allowing Avery to say or believe it does insults the Indian girl and insults my daughter.

If someone believed intelligence cannot be nurtured, cared for, built up, why would that person work in education?

I'm just grateful it didn't happen to me, at my school.

Whew.

Tuesday, September 22, 2009

Everyone's An Expert

I Hope, I Think, I Know - Oasis (mp3)
Too Much Information - The Police (mp3)


A few weeks back, I had a group of students over to my house for a meeting and munchies. When I let my dog out to piss, I noticed a very large bird -- a size somewhere between Big Bird and an emperor penguin -- crouched oddly on the hill above our house.

I kind of oohed about it, and a few of the boys followed me out, and what came next was a standard pissing contest of knowledge between males.

"Is it a hawk?" I asked.

"I think it's a falcon," said #1.

"No dumbass, it's not a falcon. Falcons are tiny. It's a hawk or an eagle," said #2.

"It's definitely an eagle. I think it's a blah blah blah Eagle," said #3. (He didn't say "blah blah blah." He said some kind of name of an eagle, but I don't remember it.)

"How would you know?"

"Because I've been a Boy Scout for, like, my whole life and worked part of last summer doing wildlife rehabilitation, you moron."

"Oh."

"So I guess it's an eagle then," I said.

"Is it hurt?" said #1.

"It looks hurt," I said. "It looks very young." (As if I can really tell this. I mean, did I think it looked young because it didn't flash its driver's license? Or because it didn't have enough gray feathers?)

"It's probably young," said Eagle Scout. "And it's not hurt. It caught some prey. That's the kind of position it gets in when it's feeding but scared. It's trying to make itself look bigger to intimidate any perceived threat."


We all looked at each other, and we nodded, and conceded to Eagle Scout's experience and wisdom. We kept watching the eagle, because it was huge and beautiful and mesmerizing. All the while, having been silently granted the Grand Poobah of All Things Eagle, Eagle Scout kept sputtering on and on about all the things he knew about eagles and birds and the first six days of creation.

After a minute or two of thinking about it, I spoke up. "You know, if he's feeding and feeling threatened, why doesn't he just grab his food and take off to a safer place?"

Eagle Scout didn't even mull it over. "Could be a pretty big animal. They can kill medium-sized dogs."

Hardly had these words finished emanating from his vocal chords when the eagle began clearly hobbling up the hill, one painstaking semi-bounce at a time. It had no prey. It was hurt.

"Um, I'm pretty sure it's hurt," #1 said. #1 isn't the sharpest knife in the drawer, but even dumb guys like pointing out obvious mistakes by those who act like they know more.

Eagle Scout tried to recover. "Well, the way an eagle tries to protect its prey from a perceived threat is a lot like how they do when they're hurt. 'Cuz, like, they want to look big and scary even if they're, you know, hurt."

But Eagle Scout had lost his cred, and that summer of wildlife rehab had lost its weight.

We went in for all of five minutes to grab a bite of dessert and so I could call my sister, who really has worked wildlife rehab for more than a decade, and by the time we got back outside, the eagle -- if the damn thing was even an eagle -- was gone. And by gone, I don't mean it hobbled further up the hill. I mean, the damn thing had clearly flown away.

So basically, here's what we know for sure about this creature: it was a bird. We don't know for sure what kind. We don't know if it got hurt or how badly. We don't know if it killed anything and ate it or didn't. We don't know jack shit. But by golly, such things never keep us from trying like hell to impress others with knowledge we don't really have.


What is it about the human condition that makes some of us feel so compelled to be experts or knowledgeable about everything even when we're not? Do you know people like this?

There's the INTERLOPER, who noses into conversations uninvited to spew his knowledge. For example, there's a group of women sitting around and talking about Manolo Blahniks or something, and The Interloper will step in and start trying to spew information about women's shoes just because he read one dang article in Cosmo at some point, drowning out the conversation while the women roll their eyes and wonder how said male ever felt invited to say anything.

Then you've got the ONE-UPPER. You're whining to a few people about the frustrations you have with your infant son. And the One-Upper, unmarried and childless, begins telling tale after tale of nephews in faraway states or the children of friends and giving all sorts of reasons why her knowledge about child-raising and the nature of parenting should carry more weight than yours.

Or how about the MONOPOLIST? The Monopolist just can't tolerate anyone questioning their knowledge on any subject, and if anyone threatens their fiefdom with an equal level of intelligence or understanding, the Monopolist feels compelled to try and drown them out like it was some shouting match on Hardball.

Most of us fall on a Bell curve when it comes to these tendencies. I'm the first to acknowledge that I can be a guilty of all three of these from time to time, particularly in matters of '80s pop culture, comic book history, or certain musical trivia. That is, I'd like to think my need to be an expert is conditional on the topic. Certain readers could probably humble me with impunity by pointing out the many examples I've conveniently omitted.

But then there's people like Eagle Scout, who go so far out on the limb of expertise -- of expertise on seemingly everything, an omni-expertise, if you will -- that it leaves the rest of us practically praying for that limb to snap just so we can stare and laugh as the expert is debunked and humbled. Unfortunately, it seems that being wrong rarely stops Expert Wannabes from continuing to be Expert Wannabes. (Insert politically-motivated insult of Rush Limbaugh here.)

At times you want to feel sorry for Expert Wannabes, because you know it's a sign of wanting acceptance, of seeking approval through knowledge they sometimes don't possess and other times wield with all the grace of Daffy Duck with the quarterstaff. But eventually, if their timing is off, they wail away at you so frequently and so mercilessly that your defenses of politeness and pity can simply no longer withstand the barrage, and you're left to seethe or explode.

Oh. By the way, that eagle? It was a Red-Tailed Hawk.

Wednesday, August 5, 2009

The Smarties' Club

Rosanne Cash--"Man Smart, Woman Smarter" (mp3)

Man has his wit, but woman has her way. --magnet on my refrigerator

Early in the summer, I got cornered at a couple of parties by a woman I know who, to be blunt, seems to have low self-esteem and needs to talk about herself a lot. The first time, we got ambushed as a couple by their couple (her and her husband), and my wife tried to retreat into her Blackberry while I tried to keep my focus on the pita chips and hummus dip until, finally, unable to take it anymore, we flat-out fled the party. Yep, just left abruptly with some lame excuse involving our children, who happen to be 16 and 20 and don't particularly need us to be home.

The second time, I got trapped alone with her alone somewhere between the drink station and a couch with nowhere to go and she had had some wine, and so proceeded to talk about being smart. She knew she was smart. She thought I was smart. She referenced someone else she knew who was smarter than either one of us. She went around the room, pointing out people and telling me that we were both smarter than each particular person. It was kind of like it was some kind of exclusive club.

I didn't say anything, just kind of nodded, acquiesced a little too much, looked for someone to bail me out. It reminded me a little of that scene from The Great Gatsby where Tom Buchanan is spouting racist nonsense and identifying himself and everyone else at his dinner party members of a "dominant race" that have to protect civilization from the lesser races.

And, yeah, I'm probably smarter than your average bear. Big fuckin' deal. I'm smart, you're smart, we're all smart, and then there are those who are smarter. And those who aren't. Big. Fuckin'. Deal. I'm also clever, can be quite clever. I may be able to put two ideas together more quickly than you can, or spin words for a laugh. And I'm quick. Yeah, fast as lightning with the irony. And I've got a good memory. Can remember details, song lyrics, not necessarily lines from movies.

What does it all add up to? I'm probably someone that you might want at your dinner party in hopes that I might make the table laugh once or twice and maybe someone you'd want on your Celebrity team or Encore team or _______ (insert favorite game here) because I know the story behind Deep Purple's "Smoke On The Water" and am conversational about hip-hop culture.

To traffic in your own intelligence--IQ, grades, test scores, whatever--as an adult is a pointless exercise and kind of a pathetic one at that. Smarts are best left to schoolyard bragging and, maybe, to the oneupsmanship that may still be important to a young adult before skills in a marriage, a family, a job, a civic organization matter more. Intelligence may get your foot in the door, but it isn't going to get you the job, the special project, the promotion. Or the girl.

Still, at first glance, we'd all like to think that we're in the Smarties club. Intelligence is something that we tend to use as a dividing line; the lack of intelligence is a basis for criticism, condescension, judgement against a policy we didn't like. And no one wants to be on the other side. Telling your boss that you disagree with him or her is one thing. Telling him that his plan is stupid is likely to draw a different reaction. And if you're the President and you tell the Cambridge Police Department that they behaved "stupidly," you're probably going to wish you had chosen different words, especially if both you and the victim in the case have Ivy League pedigrees.

Since Billy talked out about Outliers yesterday and I've just read it too, I'll point out a couple things in Gladwell's book:

1. The smartest man in the world (by far) is a guy named Chris Langan who has worked as a bouncer for the last 20 years and couldn't figure out how to deal with the bureaucracy effectively so that he could finish college. (The second-smartest, of course, thinks she's the smartest and answers brain teasers for Parade magazine).

2. One of the researchers Gladwell talks about in his book explains that after a certain point IQ doesn't matter. All that matters is that a person is "smart enough," not that he or she is smarter than everyone else in the room. The baseline intelligence he references, while above average, is not particularly high, just high enough to allow all of us to gripe, "I'm smarter than my boss" and still realize that somehow he or she is smart enough to be the boss.

I suspect that maybe the club we really want to be in (half-kidding, of course) is that Smart Enough Club, that group of people who are fortunate enough to be armed with enough something upstairs to be able to navigate their way through life without too much outside help.

Ultimately, intelligence is like money. Great things can be accomplished with it, but there is no great joy in its accumulation. To wear it around one's neck like a gaudy piece of jewelry that says to the world, "Look what I've got," is to worship it for its own sake, which has never amounted to anything. In fact, having too much of intelligence, like money, probably undermines both a person's motivation and sense of purpose. Spend all of your time thinking that you're smart, knowing that your smart, having people tell you that you're smart, and you'll probably find yourself in a terminal condition of smartness. Incurable. Doomed to believe that you deserve things from other people because you've read all of Jane Austen's novels and went to fine schools and quote Latin phrases at the drop of a hat.

But, surely, all of that means something?

Yes, honey, the game is called Trivial Pursuit.

Rosanne Cash is available at Itunes.