Little Mystery - Todd Thibaud (mp3)
Bob doesn’t like anonymous commenters. They are the green eggs and ham of his existence. He prefers people with names. People like troutking, gooftyakemyhand, Thom Anon, Daisy, cinderkeys, BeckEye.
I find Bob’s prejudices in this matter to be entirely weird.
Of the people whose pseudonyms I’ve listed above -- loyal or semi-loyal readers one and all -- Bob only knows three of them well. He knows little or nothing of the other three. Nothing, that is, except a made-up name that re-emerges with new comments.
Do they have spouses or children? What are their career interests or personal aspirations? Are they religious? Do they own firearms? Have they ever stalked someone on Facebook? Bob doesn’t know. And, more importantly, Bob doesn’t really care.*
Which is precisely why I don’t quite understand why he gets so annoyed with anonymous comments like the one he received following his Damning-With-Faint-Damnation write-up about the Avett Brothers.
The Anonymous In Question (I hereby name him “TAIQ”) wrote a sincere response to Bob’s negative slant on the Avett Brothers. He (she?) wasn’t trolling. He wasn’t insulting Bob. He was just begging to differ and sharing his own degree of interest in and passion for the band in question. I would think -- and perhaps Bob will correct me -- that the kinds of comments TAIQ offered are precisely the kind of honest counterpoints for which one might hope to receive from the outside world when writing an opinion piece on a blog.
What if TAIQ named himself “TAIQ”? Or Jimmy, or Papa Smurf, or Dick Cheney’s Pet Giraffe? This somehow would have comforted Bob. At least, that’s the impression one can rightly get from Bob’s frequently put-off replies to people who simply choose to keep the name “Anonymous.”
One of my favorite movie moments of the last 20 years -- and one of the most powerful American literature moments of the last century -- is the scene where John Proctor screams and beseeches the mortal judges of his fate to leave him his name in the film adaptation of “The Crucible.” (Skip to the 3:15 mark to see the clip. Every single time I watch it, I get very misty.)
If we all had to post our names -- our real, full, completely identifiable names -- on all the doors to all the places we visit or pass by, both in the real world and online, perhaps we would be more respectful of our own decision-making. We might better honor our names and our souls if we were required to own up in toto to all our words and deeds.
But then, how to defend that the entire foundation of Bottom of the Glass is built on anonymity? From day one, Bob and I determined we could not, with sufficient comfort and confidence, write our honest and blunt opinions about things unless we keep our identities all but private. That’s right; this entire blog is written by two mostly-anonymous people who choose to reveal only what they wish to reveal about themselves.
Were our full names on BOTG, the entire tone and personality of this endeavor would shift. It would become safer, stiffer, and more vanilla than a venti Starbucks latte. Instead, having just the slightest veneer of identity protection frees us up to be a version of ourselves that need not care about our paycheck security, our colleague security, our church security, whatever.
It is not a lie, our semi-anonymity, anymore than Clark Kent is a lie. It is a reminder that we all create personae to fit specific crowds and times. (If you have somehow fooled yourself into thinking you are immune from this peccadillo, sleep well with your self-delusion.)
To TAIQ and others out there in our Anonymous Universe: all we’d really like -- but don’t by any means demand -- is some basic, simple, and yes ultimately still-anonymous way of identifying you that separates you ever so slightly from all those other anonymous people we don’t know.
We both sincerely hope you’ll have been intrigued or annoyed enough to return and share in future conversations!
* - This lack of care does not speak ill of Bob. It is the natural inclination of almost all of us to not care about the life details of people with whom we have no actual expected interactions in the near or far future. It’s tough enough for most of us to care about the life details of people we actually care about and work or live with, much less those we hardly know.
Showing posts with label anonymity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label anonymity. Show all posts
Wednesday, January 19, 2011
Sunday, February 28, 2010
The "Pleasures" of Anonymity
Camera Obscura--"Let's Get Out Of This Country" (mp3)
And You Will Know Us By The Trail of Dead--"Source Tags and Codes" (mp3)
While goofing around the Internet this afternoon, I came upon a "best of" list of songs, the one that is referenced at the end of this post. I was excited because I didn't know most of the songs. And the people who commented on the post were mostly complimentary as well. All except one. Anonymous wrote the following: "This is the worst Top 50 list I have ever seen."
If it isn't already gone, anonymity may soon become a thing of the past. Cameras, PIN #s, tracking codes, hidden GPS's in our cell phones, just about every aspect of life makes it no longer possible to fly under the radar, or, better put, under the satellites' all-seeing eyes. Think about it. What can you still do that you can do without anyone knowing that you are doing it or knowing who you are? That may not be a big deal to you; to me, it is the essence of freedom.
And please be clear about one thing: there isn't anything secretive that I want to do. At least, nothing comes immediately to mind.
But I am enough of a child of the early 70's, though, to think that this abolition of anonymity is not a good thing. And, enough of a historian to know that from the Federalist Papers in the early days of the republic to "Deep Throat" at the height of the Watergate cover-up, a person's ability to remain anonymous was crucial to moving our country forward.
This year, all kinds of people are calling for reform concerning the use of traffic cameras here in Tennessee. I have always been opposed to them. I know that they can and do save lies--that is not the controlling issue for me. Instead, I embrace the idea that what a person does inside of his or her car that he or she can get away with is okay. Our school also has cameras all over the place. They help to solve crimes, especially theft, when crimes are committed. Someone, probably a friend of mine, pours over hours of tapes trying to identify the most likely student to have committed the crime. Often, he solves them. I am still opposed to the cameras.
The idea that cameras are everywhere, watching and recording us, is disturbing. The idea that every place we go on a computer is recorded is intrusive. The idea that every word we speak into a telephone can be reviewed somewhere is disconcerting. And wrong. As is the recently-revealed fact that our phone companies can track us using our cell phones any time they want to.
Safety is important to me; privacy is more important. Must one be sacrificed in favor of the other? I don't think so. There is no doubt that things changed after 9/11, but we have never, as a country, had the philosophical discussion we needed to have, instead arguing in our own minds that things had to change and that there was nothing that we could/should do about it. I have argued this point more than once, usually with people who adopt a stance of "I don't care about this; I don't have anything to hide."
Well, I don't have anything to hide either. At least, not now. But I might someday and it might be something worth hiding.
I am one of those people who ponders anonymous acts, but then never does them, out of fear that they really won't be anonymous. You know, would like to put posters around that say what I really think or write on bathroom stall walls to clarify what really happened in a given situation. But I don't.
There is a competing school of thought which argues that if you have something to say, you need to have the balls to say it directly, openly, publicly. But that isn't always prudent or safe. Depending on the situational or historical context, doing so would get you fired, imprisoned, or even shot. And that implies a world where a range of opinions are welcome. But are they? Even in this most open of societies, what we have to say can get us into all kinds of trouble. Personally, I have yet to know a person in charge of something who, though he or she claims to want honest feedback, doesn't get angry when it comes. Nationally, I have yet to see us embrace with open arms the person who challenges the status quo.
There is also a pragmatic perspective which argues that we should use every bit of technology at our disposal to intervene on potential crimes and acts of terrorism before they occur, but the power this puts in the hands of the watchers is terrifying to me; it invites scenarios like the ones in the movie, Minority Report.
There should be anonymous outlets for expression. One of the great ironies of the open society people like me crave is that we want sometimes to be able to hide behind that cloak or anonymity. Instead, there are apparently-anonymous outlets. But if someone wants to know who you are, there are ways of finding out.
I remember when a teacher was fired during my first year of teaching, I pondered many nights when I was over making copies leaving a note which addressed the situation. I wanted to ask the faculty as a whole why no one had made any comment about the firing of a colleague. It was a very confusing and troubling time for a new teacher. Surely, I thought, someone was upset about it, someone would protest. But they didn't. And I never left my note. I thought that my note would somehow identify me as that lone person who would dare to stir up trouble regarding the firing.
On a lighter note, these days, an entire portion of my childhood is no longer possible. I remember those 6th and 7th grade years when, during a sleepover at someone's house, we would call up the all-night radio shows and pretend to be someone that we weren't. I remember taking on a British accent for the Jack somebody show and us calling about 1 AM, trying to stifle our giggles, and me saying, in poor Brit-speak, "I'm an avid bird watcher, and I'd like to talk to Jack about birds." Of course, the producer or whomever answered the phone knew that we were kids, and dealt with us accordingly, but the fact that he couldn't quite know who or what we were gave us confidence to keep trying.
Nowadays, when a student uses an Internet service for deaf people to send a message to a faculty member that he would "like to put his beef in [her] taco," the tech staff quickly zeroes in on the exact computer that the message was sent from and he finds himself suspended. Maybe he should be. Maybe that's a heinous crime; it certainly tends towards sexual harassment. Or maybe it's just the modern variation of the prank phone calls that everyone from my generation used to make.
I know we've got to track down the creepos who hide behind secret identities, but if your refrigerator is running, I guess I'd still like to be able to call you up and tell you that you'd better go catch it. Do we really live in a society where there are so many people that need watching that we need to watch everyone all the time?
Both songs come from a terrific "Best Songs Of The Decade" list over at Heart Ache With Hard Work.
And You Will Know Us By The Trail of Dead--"Source Tags and Codes" (mp3)
While goofing around the Internet this afternoon, I came upon a "best of" list of songs, the one that is referenced at the end of this post. I was excited because I didn't know most of the songs. And the people who commented on the post were mostly complimentary as well. All except one. Anonymous wrote the following: "This is the worst Top 50 list I have ever seen."
Cowardly? Shitty? Perhaps. If he was going to be so critical, why couldn't he be man enough to reveal his identity? Or hers. Maybe there were reasons. Maybe there were reasons I also used anonymity to respond positively to one of Billy's posts last week.
If it isn't already gone, anonymity may soon become a thing of the past. Cameras, PIN #s, tracking codes, hidden GPS's in our cell phones, just about every aspect of life makes it no longer possible to fly under the radar, or, better put, under the satellites' all-seeing eyes. Think about it. What can you still do that you can do without anyone knowing that you are doing it or knowing who you are? That may not be a big deal to you; to me, it is the essence of freedom.And please be clear about one thing: there isn't anything secretive that I want to do. At least, nothing comes immediately to mind.
But I am enough of a child of the early 70's, though, to think that this abolition of anonymity is not a good thing. And, enough of a historian to know that from the Federalist Papers in the early days of the republic to "Deep Throat" at the height of the Watergate cover-up, a person's ability to remain anonymous was crucial to moving our country forward.
This year, all kinds of people are calling for reform concerning the use of traffic cameras here in Tennessee. I have always been opposed to them. I know that they can and do save lies--that is not the controlling issue for me. Instead, I embrace the idea that what a person does inside of his or her car that he or she can get away with is okay. Our school also has cameras all over the place. They help to solve crimes, especially theft, when crimes are committed. Someone, probably a friend of mine, pours over hours of tapes trying to identify the most likely student to have committed the crime. Often, he solves them. I am still opposed to the cameras.The idea that cameras are everywhere, watching and recording us, is disturbing. The idea that every place we go on a computer is recorded is intrusive. The idea that every word we speak into a telephone can be reviewed somewhere is disconcerting. And wrong. As is the recently-revealed fact that our phone companies can track us using our cell phones any time they want to.
Safety is important to me; privacy is more important. Must one be sacrificed in favor of the other? I don't think so. There is no doubt that things changed after 9/11, but we have never, as a country, had the philosophical discussion we needed to have, instead arguing in our own minds that things had to change and that there was nothing that we could/should do about it. I have argued this point more than once, usually with people who adopt a stance of "I don't care about this; I don't have anything to hide."Well, I don't have anything to hide either. At least, not now. But I might someday and it might be something worth hiding.
I am one of those people who ponders anonymous acts, but then never does them, out of fear that they really won't be anonymous. You know, would like to put posters around that say what I really think or write on bathroom stall walls to clarify what really happened in a given situation. But I don't.
There is a competing school of thought which argues that if you have something to say, you need to have the balls to say it directly, openly, publicly. But that isn't always prudent or safe. Depending on the situational or historical context, doing so would get you fired, imprisoned, or even shot. And that implies a world where a range of opinions are welcome. But are they? Even in this most open of societies, what we have to say can get us into all kinds of trouble. Personally, I have yet to know a person in charge of something who, though he or she claims to want honest feedback, doesn't get angry when it comes. Nationally, I have yet to see us embrace with open arms the person who challenges the status quo.
There is also a pragmatic perspective which argues that we should use every bit of technology at our disposal to intervene on potential crimes and acts of terrorism before they occur, but the power this puts in the hands of the watchers is terrifying to me; it invites scenarios like the ones in the movie, Minority Report.
There should be anonymous outlets for expression. One of the great ironies of the open society people like me crave is that we want sometimes to be able to hide behind that cloak or anonymity. Instead, there are apparently-anonymous outlets. But if someone wants to know who you are, there are ways of finding out.
I remember when a teacher was fired during my first year of teaching, I pondered many nights when I was over making copies leaving a note which addressed the situation. I wanted to ask the faculty as a whole why no one had made any comment about the firing of a colleague. It was a very confusing and troubling time for a new teacher. Surely, I thought, someone was upset about it, someone would protest. But they didn't. And I never left my note. I thought that my note would somehow identify me as that lone person who would dare to stir up trouble regarding the firing.
On a lighter note, these days, an entire portion of my childhood is no longer possible. I remember those 6th and 7th grade years when, during a sleepover at someone's house, we would call up the all-night radio shows and pretend to be someone that we weren't. I remember taking on a British accent for the Jack somebody show and us calling about 1 AM, trying to stifle our giggles, and me saying, in poor Brit-speak, "I'm an avid bird watcher, and I'd like to talk to Jack about birds." Of course, the producer or whomever answered the phone knew that we were kids, and dealt with us accordingly, but the fact that he couldn't quite know who or what we were gave us confidence to keep trying.Nowadays, when a student uses an Internet service for deaf people to send a message to a faculty member that he would "like to put his beef in [her] taco," the tech staff quickly zeroes in on the exact computer that the message was sent from and he finds himself suspended. Maybe he should be. Maybe that's a heinous crime; it certainly tends towards sexual harassment. Or maybe it's just the modern variation of the prank phone calls that everyone from my generation used to make.
I know we've got to track down the creepos who hide behind secret identities, but if your refrigerator is running, I guess I'd still like to be able to call you up and tell you that you'd better go catch it. Do we really live in a society where there are so many people that need watching that we need to watch everyone all the time?
Both songs come from a terrific "Best Songs Of The Decade" list over at Heart Ache With Hard Work.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

